Nice Loops

What are Nice Loops?

Nice Loops are master-level Sudoku techniques that represent some of the most elegant logical constructions in puzzle solving. A Nice Loop is a closed chain of alternating strong and weak inferences that circles back to its starting point, creating a self-referential logical structure.

Unlike Forcing Chains which are open-ended paths, Nice Loops form complete circuits. This circular structure is incredibly powerful: when a chain loops back to contradict its own starting assumption, you've proven that assumption must be false (or true, depending on the loop type).

Nice Loops are a generalization of many simpler techniques. X-Wing, XY-Wing, and even Remote Pairs can all be viewed as special cases of Nice Loops. Understanding loops provides a unified framework for advanced Sudoku logic.

Why are they called "Nice Loops"?

The term "Nice Loop" comes from the acronym N.I.C.E., which stands for "Network of Inference Chains with Eliminations" or similar variations (the exact origin is debated). The "nice" part also reflects their elegant mathematical structure—they're beautiful examples of circular logical reasoning.

Some solvers also call them "Cycles" or "Closed Chains," which more directly describe their circular nature.

Why They Matter

Nice Loops matter because they:

Unify many techniques — Understanding loops shows how X-Wing, XY-Wing, and other patterns are related
Solve the hardest puzzles — Many diabolical puzzles require loop-based reasoning
Provide systematic approach — Instead of memorizing dozens of patterns, learn one loop-finding method
Bridge to software solving — Computer solvers heavily use loop detection algorithms
Push logical boundaries — Represent some of the most complex pure-logic deductions possible

Step-by-Step: How to Find a Nice Loop

Start with a candidate — Choose a candidate in a cell as your starting point.
Build a chain using strong and weak links — Alternate between strong inferences (conjugate pairs) and weak inferences (cells that see each other).
Try to close the loop — Continue the chain until you can connect back to your starting candidate.
Check for even number of weak links — Continuous loops need an even number of weak links to create valid contradictions.
Identify the loop type — Determine if it's continuous (closes perfectly) or discontinuous (has gaps).
Make eliminations — Based on the contradiction created by the loop.

Types of Nice Loops

Continuous Nice Loop (CNL)

A loop that closes perfectly with an even number of weak links. The chain's end connects directly back to its start. If you assume the starting candidate is false, the chain forces it to be true—a contradiction. Therefore, the starting candidate must be true.

Example: Start with R1C1≠5 → R1C1=8 (strong) → R4C1≠8 (weak) → R4C1=5 (strong) → R1C4≠5 (weak) → R1C4=8 (strong) → R1C1≠8 (weak). This loops back, creating contradiction. Therefore R1C1=5.

Discontinuous Nice Loop (DNL)

A loop where the chain almost closes but has a weak link segment that doesn't perfectly connect. Any candidate that sees both ends of a discontinuous weak link can be eliminated (because at least one end must be true).

Example: A chain creates: R2C5=7 and R2C8=7 at different points, but R2C5 and R2C8 are both in Row 2. Any other cell in Row 2 that sees both cannot be 7.

X-Cycles

Nice Loops that use only one candidate value throughout the entire chain. These are simpler to track than mixed-candidate loops and are good starting points for learning loop logic.

Example: A loop tracking only candidate 3: R1C1=3 → R1C9≠3 → R5C9=3 → R5C1≠3 → R1C1≠3. This contradiction proves R1C1≠3.

XY-Chains

Loops through bi-value cells where each cell shares one candidate with the next. These are closely related to XY-Wing but extended to longer chains.

Visual Example

A simple continuous Nice Loop:

Start: Assume R3C3≠6
Link 1 (strong): Then R3C3=2 (only two candidates in cell)
Link 2 (weak): Then R3C7≠2 (sees R3C3)
Link 3 (strong): Then R3C7=6 (only two candidates in cell)
Link 4 (weak): Then R3C3≠6 (sees R3C7)
Loop closes: We're back to "R3C3≠6" which was our assumption!

Conclusion: The assumption "R3C3≠6" leads to itself through the loop, which would be okay, but if we trace assuming R3C3=6 instead, we get a contradiction in the opposite direction. This specific loop structure forces R3C3=2.

Strategies for Finding Nice Loops

Start with bi-value cells — These provide clear strong links for loop building.
Use software assistance — Loop detection is extremely complex manually; consider solver tools that highlight chains.
Practice with X-Cycles first — Single-candidate loops are easier to track than multi-candidate loops.
Draw diagrams — Visual representation helps track complex chains.
Learn from software — Use solving software to show you loops, then verify the logic manually.
Focus on conjugate pairs — Cells where a candidate appears exactly twice in a unit are loop building blocks.

Common Pitfalls

Odd number of weak links in continuous loops — Continuous Nice Loops require an even number of weak links to create valid contradictions.
Losing track of the chain — Long loops can have 8-12+ links. Meticulous tracking is essential.
Incorrect link types — Confusing strong and weak links invalidates the entire loop.
Missing simpler techniques — Always try simpler methods before resorting to Nice Loops.
Overreliance on software — Understanding the logic is important even if you use tools to find loops.

Practice: Identify the Loop Type

Scenario: You build a chain: R1C1=5 (start) → R1C9≠5 (weak) → R1C9=3 (strong) → R7C9≠3 (weak) → R7C9=5 (strong) → R1C1≠5 (weak, loops back).

Question: Is this a continuous or discontinuous Nice Loop, and what can you conclude?

Answer: This is a continuous Nice Loop with 3 weak links (odd number). With an odd number of weak links, the starting assumption creates a contradiction. If R1C1=5 is assumed true, the chain forces R1C1≠5. Therefore, the assumption is false: R1C1≠5. You can eliminate 5 from R1C1.

Why Nice Loops Matter

Nice Loops represent the pinnacle of pattern-based logical deduction in Sudoku. They matter because they:

Provide solutions when all other logical techniques fail
Unify dozens of seemingly different techniques under one framework
Bridge human logical reasoning with algorithmic solving approaches
Demonstrate the depth and beauty of Sudoku's logical structure

While challenging to apply manually, understanding Nice Loops deepens appreciation for the puzzle's mathematical elegance and provides the ultimate logical tool for the hardest Sudoku challenges.

Quick Recap

Technique	How it Works	Difficulty
Nice Loops	Closed chains that loop back to starting point, creating contradictions	Master
Forcing Chains	Open chains where multiple paths converge on same conclusion	Master
XY-Wing	Short 3-cell chain pattern (special case of loops)	Advanced

Final Thought

Nice Loops are the ultimate expression of Sudoku's logical beauty—elegant circular arguments that prove impossibility through self-contradiction. While mastering them requires dedication, understanding loops transforms your solving from memorizing patterns to truly understanding the deep logical structure of Sudoku.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Nice Loops in Sudoku?

Nice Loops are master-level Sudoku techniques involving closed chains of logical inferences. Unlike open forcing chains, Nice Loops form complete circles where the chain connects back to its starting point, creating contradictions that allow eliminations or placements.

How do Nice Loops differ from Forcing Chains?

Forcing Chains are open-ended paths that branch from a starting point and converge on a conclusion. Nice Loops are closed circuits that loop back to the start. This circular structure creates self-contradicting patterns that prove candidates must be true or false.

What are continuous vs discontinuous Nice Loops?

Continuous Nice Loops have an even number of weak links and create direct contradictions—if you try to set the starting candidate false, the loop forces it to be true. Discontinuous Nice Loops have weak links that don't close perfectly, allowing eliminations in cells that see both ends of a weak link segment.

Are Nice Loops practical for manual solving?

Nice Loops are challenging for manual solving due to their complexity and the difficulty of spotting closed chains. However, understanding them helps recognize when simpler techniques won't work and provides a systematic approach for the hardest puzzles. Many solvers use software assistance for loop detection.

What techniques are special cases of Nice Loops?

Many advanced techniques are Nice Loop variants: X-Cycles are Nice Loops using only one candidate, XY-Chains are loops through bi-value cells, and even patterns like X-Wing and XY-Wing can be viewed as short Nice Loops. Understanding loops unifies these seemingly different techniques.

Practice Nice Loops

Printable Expert Sudoku

Ready for more master techniques? Try ALS Chains or Forcing Chains.

← Back to All Strategies